Richmond’s top prosecutor won’t reopen Marcus-David Peters investigation

Richmond

RICHMOND, Va. (WRIC) — Richmond’s top prosecutor will not reopen the investigation into the death of Marcus-David Peters, a high school teacher who was fatally shot by a Richmond police officer in 2018 while experiencing an apparent mental health crisis alongside Interstate-95, concluding that the officer’s decision to use lethal force was justified in a report made public Friday.

Peters’ family had pushed for the case to be reopened, with his sister saying that he needed help during the incident, “not death.” Restarting the investigation was also one of the priorities for protesters during the summer amid demonstrations against police brutality and racism.

Richmond’s Commonwealth’s Attorney Colette McEachin agreed to review the case when calls to reopen it grew but did not guarantee any further investigation. On Friday, McEachin shared a 10-page report detailing the case’s findings and concluded that the officer made “a reasonable response” in the deadly shooting.

“Based upon my review of the Analysis and of the evidence listed therein, the additional evidence requested and discussed above, the applicable law, and the totality of the circumstances surrounding this devastating event, the officer’s ultimate decision to use lethal force was a reasonable response to the imminent danger presented to himself and the public by Mr. Peters’ continued violent behavior due to his mental deterioration,” McEachin wrote in the report’s conclusion.

According to police reports, an officer, later identified as Michael Nyantakyi, witnessed Peters’ vehicle strike another car near the intersection of N. Belvidere Street and W. Franklin Street on May 14, 2018. Peters did not stop when Nyantakyi tried to pull him over and hit two other vehicles before coming to a stop in the center of the ramp of Interstate-95 North, police said.

Footage from the incident showed a naked and unarmed Peters run towards the highway and into traffic before being hit by a car. Peters was then seen lying in the right travel lane and rolling over in the road.

“After being struck by the car, Mr. Peters got up immediately, but then laid back down in the travel lane for several seconds where he repeatedly rolled over in a tumbling motion. He then moved to the shoulder of the roadway, where he again laid on the ground moving his arms and legs as if making snow angels,” the report from McEachin stated. “Mr. Peters can be heard talking to himself while he thrashed and rolled on the shoulder of the travel lane. For several seconds, he rolled and tumbled on the pavement. At one point he stopped, laid flat on his back, then sat up suddenly and said ‘I figured it out – I’m living the dream.’ By this point, the officer had already notified DEC that Mr. Peters had been struck, and he had again requested additional units. In his interview, the officer explained that Mr. Peters seemed unaffected by the vehicle impact or the abrasive conditions of the roadway.”

The officer took out his taser while moving closer to check on Peters, who then stood up and eventually said “put that taser down or I’ll kill you” to the officer in the body camera footage. Peters could be heard cursing at Nyantakyi while moving towards him.

Nyantakyi deployed his taser and struck Peters with one prong but it appeared to have no effect, police said. McEachin described her office’s findings on the deadly shooting in the report released Friday.

“Nude and unarmed, Mr. Peters advanced closer and lunged at the officer with his arms extended in what appeared to be an effort to grab him. In his interview, the officer acknowledged that Mr. Peters was unarmed, but he indicated that by this point, it was ‘an all-out fight between the two’ of them to gain control over his firearm,” McEachin wrote. “The officer further explained that he was wary of engaging hand to hand with Mr. Peters because of his erratic behavior, his unresponsiveness to pain, and fear that Mr. Peters might land on top of him. Using his left arm to repel him, the officer explained that he ‘bladed’ his body to shield his firearm from Mr. Peters. As Mr. Peters continued to charge in apparent attack, the officer fired at least twice. It is unclear whether Mr. Peters actually made contact before the shots were fired; although, in the footage he was certainly well within arm’s length.”

Peters fell to the ground after he was shot, eventually standing up and walking towards some bushes in the area before collapsing. He was taken to VCU Health where he died shortly after midnight. The final autopsy report showed Peters had been shot three times, twice in the abdomen and once in the left forearm.

The announcement from McEachin comes a day after Gov. Ralph Northam (D) signed legislation referred to as the “Marcus Alert” bill, a measure that will require police departments in Virginia to follow protocols in the Marcus Alert System, which will be developed by the Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) and the Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (DBHDS), while responding to emergency calls involving people who are experiencing a mental health crisis by 2026.

This story is developing. Check back for updates.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

StormTracker 8

Trending Stories

More Trending Stories

Local Events